Home > Butterknife > 2324 Starfish Ln, Sanibel, FL 33957
fiber_manual_record For Sale - Active

2324 Starfish Ln, Sanibel, FL 33957 - 3 Bedroom Home in Butterknife

$1,899,000

MLS Number
2025011326
Bedrooms
3 Bed
Bathrooms
2 Baths + 1 Half
Living Area
3,183 sq ft
Total Area
6,233 sq ft
Garage Spaces
2
Year Built
2017
Days on Market
11

home Property Description

Behind the private gates of the only gated community along West Gulf Drive awaits a residence where refined coastal living meets enduring strength. Completed in 2017 to uncompromising standards and stringent hurricane codes, this architectural gem was designed for peace of mind and timeless elegance. Set on a 1.5-acre homesite, the property offers an enviable balance of privacy and proximity, just steps from a magnificent stretch of white sand beach and framed by endless views of hundreds of acres of preserved coastal hammock. Residents enjoy privileged access to two deeded beach pathways, three tennis courts, a pickleball court, and a large community pool with covered patio areas and convenient restrooms. Inside, soaring two-story ceilings crown the great room, where custom LED-illuminated built-ins, a shiplap accent wall, and a sleek linear fireplace create an atmosphere both dramatic and welcoming. The chef’s kitchen was recently reimagined with marble-inspired quartz countertops, herringbone tile backsplash, new hardware, designer pendants, and a bespoke coffee bar—perfect for morning rituals or effortless entertaining. The thoughtful floor plan situates the primary suite on the main level, offering a retreat of quiet sophistication, while guest suites upstairs ensure comfort and privacy for family and friends. Spa-like baths, engineered wood flooring, and custom lighting lend subtle luxury throughout, while fresh interior paint brightens every corner with coastal ease. No detail was overlooked in enhancing durability and efficiency: impact-rated windows and doors, additional hurricane strapping, Hardie board siding, and in 2023, a new flat roof paired with a standing seam colored metal roof boasting a 35-year manufacturer’s warranty. Together, these elements provide both beauty and resilience—qualities that translate into favorable insurance premiums and long-term confidence. From sunrise over the preserve to sunset on the Gulf, this home embodies the essence of Sanibel living: strength, serenity, and style, just moments from one of America’s most celebrated beaches.

hangout_video Virtual Tour

fact_check The Basics

Property Type Single Family
Gulf Access No
Private Pool No
Private Spa No
Acres 1.517
Furnished Furnished
Last Modified 1 week ago

savings Financials & HOA Fees

Foreclosure No
Auction No
Short Sale Yes
Mandatory HOA Yes
HOA Fee $2,250 annually

roofing Building Features

Building Style 2 Story, See Remarks, Traditional
Cooling Ceiling Fan(s), Central Electric
Covered Spaces 2
Elevator None
Floor Plan 2 Story
Floors 2
Garage Spaces 2
Patio and Porch Deck
Other Structures Tennis Court(s)
Rear Exposure Northwest
Roof Metal
Security Features Gated Community
Storm Protection Impact Resistant Doors, Impact Resistant Windows
View Landscaped Area, Preserve
Water Source Central

Would you like to schedule a private showing of this property?

Let's talk about what the buying process would look like for this property.

chair Interior Features

Appliances & Equipment Cooktop - Electric, Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Microwave, Refrigerator, Wall Oven, Washer
Interior Features Cathedral Ceiling(s), Fireplace
Additional Rooms Laundry in Residence, Loft, Screened Lanai/Porch
Flooring Carpet, Tile, Wood
Gas No
Laundry Laundry in Residence

holiday_village Neighborhood and Community

Pets Allowed Yes
Amenities Barbecue, Beach Access, Pool, Pickleball, Tennis Court(s)
Neighborhood Butterknife
Neighborhood Type Gated
Community Features Pool, Tennis Court(s), Gated
Included in Fees Legal/Accounting, Manager, Other, Rec Facilities
HOA Restrictions None/Other

travel_luggage_and_bags Leasing Rules

Lease Limits Yes
Leases Per Year 12
Minimum Days of Lease 30

photo_library Additional Images

Chris Farrugia, REALTOR Portrait

Chris Farrugia, M.B.A.

Realtor® at The Listing Naples Group

📞 (239) 248-8171
📧 chris@listingnaples.com

Mortgage Calculator

Estimate your monthly mortgage payment.

Similar Nearby Listings

partner_exchange Broker Reciprocity

The source of this real property information is the copyrighted and proprietary database compilation of the Southwest Florida MLS organizations. Copyright 2025 Southwest Florida MLS organizations. All rights reserved. The accuracy of this information is not warranted or guaranteed. This information should be independently verified if any person intends to engage in a transaction in reliance upon it.

Listing provided by Premier Sotheby's Int'l Realty.